{ "schemaVersion": 1, "kind": "browser-approved-live-bramble-qualification", "observedAt": "2026-11-11T04:59:44.999Z", "source": "live_sandbox", "faultSource": "local response-only interruption", "checks": [ { "name": "Actual separate live sandbox L2 revisions", "passed": true }, { "name": "Baseline records two distinct orders and completed gross captures", "passed": true }, { "name": "Baseline gives one book only after the second response", "passed": true }, { "name": "Separate compensation preserves the original failed verdict", "passed": true }, { "name": "Refund is bound to the exact second capture", "passed": true }, { "name": "Independent provider reads confirm both original baseline captures", "passed": true }, { "name": "Independent provider read confirms the original completed refund", "passed": true }, { "name": "Hardened target retains one original order, capture and book", "passed": true }, { "name": "Hardened unchanged payment invariants pass", "passed": true }, { "name": "Independent provider read confirms the original control capture", "passed": true }, { "name": "faulty: capture was observed before the controlled response loss", "passed": true }, { "name": "faulty: every distinct order has a buyer approval receipt", "passed": true }, { "name": "hardened: capture was observed before the controlled response loss", "passed": true }, { "name": "hardened: every distinct order has a buyer approval receipt", "passed": true }, { "name": "Baseline reports failure before the separate customer retry", "passed": true }, { "name": "Hardened checking precedes resource reconciliation and fulfillment", "passed": true } ], "passed": true, "summary": { "baseline": { "grossMinor": 2400, "refundMinor": 1200, "fulfillments": 1, "verdict": "fail" }, "control": { "grossMinor": 1200, "fulfillments": 1, "verdict": "pass" } }, "runs": [ { "id": "2a850002-2df8-456f-b760-59c1055ccaea", "revision": "faulty", "sourceHash": "61b06912303d96bb8b9f27f6707bf682c4d5588e342a7489bf7ef300ae21a4a2", "scenarioHash": "cc468b6346ef48908a0b2de11e9266e4e7e22cf2c23da07d665d6290b082e23c", "businessIntentId": "purchase-0d368aa4-f6dd-4365-9647-c77f8455914f", "orderIds": [ "7KN35440AK973631C", "54142017F86464930" ], "captures": [ { "id": "5X59700848833580D", "orderId": "7KN35440AK973631C", "status": "COMPLETED", "amountMinor": 1200, "currency": "USD", "observedAt": "2026-11-11T04:53:07.761Z", "source": "live_sandbox", "evidenceId": "409871be-b7b5-4167-ac5c-d89a7d300267" }, { "id": "6PL28570JN503694M", "orderId": "54142017F86464930", "status": "COMPLETED", "amountMinor": 1200, "currency": "USD", "observedAt": "2026-11-11T04:57:16.789Z", "source": "live_sandbox", "evidenceId": "00545861-f793-4a88-8820-84173e24062a" } ], "refunds": [ { "id": "2TY77369FW268003W", "captureId": "6PL28570JN503694M", "status": "COMPLETED", "amountMinor": 1200, "currency": "USD", "observedAt": "2026-11-11T04:57:18.715Z", "source": "live_sandbox", "evidenceId": "3aaf6ecb-0729-45ac-a1e0-b190a8f8a6c9" } ], "events": [ { "id": "92d2dacd-8cbe-4c54-8366-a1df70a7b2bf", "sequence": 1, "kind": "checkout_started", "lane": "application", "identity": "absent", "projection": { "phoneState": "ready", "applicationStatus": "UNPAID", "providerStatus": "NO PAYMENT", "capturedMinor": 0, "refundedMinor": 0, "captureCount": 0, "fulfillmentCount": 0, "currency": "USD" } }, { "id": "e79d7eec-2e65-4ff4-8368-05e8a426e279", "sequence": 2, "kind": "order_payer_action_required", "lane": "provider", "resourceId": "7KN35440AK973631C", "identity": "absent", "projection": { "phoneState": "ready", "applicationStatus": "UNPAID", "providerStatus": "ORDER CREATED", "capturedMinor": 0, "refundedMinor": 0, "captureCount": 0, "fulfillmentCount": 0, "currency": "USD" } }, { "id": "6f09f01f-2b44-4fad-89f9-600ec78c9622", "sequence": 3, "kind": "resource_read", "lane": "provider", "resourceId": "7KN35440AK973631C", "identity": "absent", "projection": { "phoneState": "ready", "applicationStatus": "UNPAID", "providerStatus": "ORDER CREATED", "capturedMinor": 0, "refundedMinor": 0, "captureCount": 0, "fulfillmentCount": 0, "currency": "USD" } }, { "id": "03ed9d4f-330a-4f42-ba63-4abd15f334e5", "sequence": 4, "kind": "resource_read", "lane": "provider", "resourceId": "7KN35440AK973631C", "identity": "absent", "projection": { "phoneState": "ready", "applicationStatus": "UNPAID", "providerStatus": "ORDER APPROVED", "capturedMinor": 0, "refundedMinor": 0, "captureCount": 0, "fulfillmentCount": 0, "currency": "USD" } }, { "id": "fc767dea-7b85-4169-93e4-1a86f2c53c6a", "sequence": 5, "kind": "buyer_approved", "lane": "customer", "resourceId": "7KN35440AK973631C", "identity": "not_applicable", "projection": { "phoneState": "ready", "applicationStatus": "UNPAID", "providerStatus": "ORDER APPROVED", "capturedMinor": 0, "refundedMinor": 0, "captureCount": 0, "fulfillmentCount": 0, "currency": "USD" } }, { "id": "daa34376-1123-4f11-a218-87fc13776029", "sequence": 6, "kind": "capture_completed", "lane": "provider", "resourceId": "5X59700848833580D", "identity": "absent", "projection": { "phoneState": "ready", "applicationStatus": "UNPAID", "providerStatus": "CAPTURE COMPLETED", "capturedMinor": 1200, "refundedMinor": 0, "captureCount": 1, "fulfillmentCount": 0, "currency": "USD" } }, { "id": "fb54204a-42d1-460d-b403-34e49fedadb0", "sequence": 7, "kind": "response_dropped", "lane": "lab", "identity": "not_applicable", "projection": { "phoneState": "ready", "applicationStatus": "UNPAID", "providerStatus": "CAPTURE COMPLETED", "capturedMinor": 1200, "refundedMinor": 0, "captureCount": 1, "fulfillmentCount": 0, "currency": "USD" } }, { "id": "39f2231c-4892-4bdc-bad6-1ec79735ce51", "sequence": 8, "kind": "unknown_outcome_presented_failed", "lane": "application", "identity": "not_applicable", "projection": { "phoneState": "failed", "applicationStatus": "FAILED", "providerStatus": "CAPTURE COMPLETED", "capturedMinor": 1200, "refundedMinor": 0, "captureCount": 1, "fulfillmentCount": 0, "currency": "USD" } }, { "id": "90e3d1df-7700-4157-98c8-371f12d92d85", "sequence": 9, "kind": "customer_retry", "lane": "customer", "identity": "absent", "projection": { "phoneState": "failed", "applicationStatus": "FAILED", "providerStatus": "CAPTURE COMPLETED", "capturedMinor": 1200, "refundedMinor": 0, "captureCount": 1, "fulfillmentCount": 0, "currency": "USD" } }, { "id": "3930507a-3d15-4135-bc6d-6c9ab35dc22d", "sequence": 10, "kind": "order_payer_action_required", "lane": "provider", "resourceId": "54142017F86464930", "identity": "absent", "projection": { "phoneState": "failed", "applicationStatus": "FAILED", "providerStatus": "CAPTURE COMPLETED", "capturedMinor": 1200, "refundedMinor": 0, "captureCount": 1, "fulfillmentCount": 0, "currency": "USD" } }, { "id": "28481838-3d34-4aa7-8300-b9f7de168733", "sequence": 11, "kind": "resource_read", "lane": "provider", "resourceId": "54142017F86464930", "identity": "absent", "projection": { "phoneState": "ready", "applicationStatus": "UNPAID", "providerStatus": "CAPTURE COMPLETED", "capturedMinor": 1200, "refundedMinor": 0, "captureCount": 1, "fulfillmentCount": 0, "currency": "USD" } }, { "id": "4809cd57-b195-446c-8495-4fa824be48e6", "sequence": 12, "kind": "resource_read", "lane": "provider", "resourceId": "54142017F86464930", "identity": "absent", "projection": { "phoneState": "ready", "applicationStatus": "UNPAID", "providerStatus": "CAPTURE COMPLETED", "capturedMinor": 1200, "refundedMinor": 0, "captureCount": 1, "fulfillmentCount": 0, "currency": "USD" } }, { "id": "5b9a1be7-a506-402c-a52d-9e5e611385c1", "sequence": 13, "kind": "buyer_approved", "lane": "customer", "resourceId": "54142017F86464930", "identity": "not_applicable", "projection": { "phoneState": "ready", "applicationStatus": "UNPAID", "providerStatus": "CAPTURE COMPLETED", "capturedMinor": 1200, "refundedMinor": 0, "captureCount": 1, "fulfillmentCount": 0, "currency": "USD" } }, { "id": "4a1becc9-4e74-43ee-869b-07d56c86e5d4", "sequence": 14, "kind": "capture_completed", "lane": "provider", "resourceId": "6PL28570JN503694M", "identity": "absent", "projection": { "phoneState": "ready", "applicationStatus": "UNPAID", "providerStatus": "CAPTURE COMPLETED", "capturedMinor": 2400, "refundedMinor": 0, "captureCount": 2, "fulfillmentCount": 0, "currency": "USD" } }, { "id": "9528feca-9c28-43e2-9b76-8d5f46db6345", "sequence": 15, "kind": "fulfilled", "lane": "application", "resourceId": "6PL28570JN503694M", "identity": "absent", "projection": { "phoneState": "paid", "applicationStatus": "PAID", "providerStatus": "CAPTURE COMPLETED", "capturedMinor": 2400, "refundedMinor": 0, "captureCount": 2, "fulfillmentCount": 1, "currency": "USD" } }, { "id": "46738660-05fd-4099-abbb-2d23e5759c76", "sequence": 16, "kind": "live_compensation_approved", "lane": "lab", "resourceId": "6PL28570JN503694M", "identity": "not_applicable", "projection": { "phoneState": "paid", "applicationStatus": "PAID", "providerStatus": "CAPTURE COMPLETED", "capturedMinor": 2400, "refundedMinor": 0, "captureCount": 2, "fulfillmentCount": 1, "currency": "USD" } }, { "id": "bf82fee2-5e54-47e3-8ec1-01f371b76d28", "sequence": 17, "kind": "resource_read", "lane": "provider", "resourceId": "6PL28570JN503694M", "identity": "absent", "projection": { "phoneState": "paid", "applicationStatus": "PAID", "providerStatus": "CAPTURE COMPLETED", "capturedMinor": 2400, "refundedMinor": 0, "captureCount": 2, "fulfillmentCount": 1, "currency": "USD" } }, { "id": "86fac83d-eb1f-450b-9408-1f5366349a17", "sequence": 18, "kind": "resource_read", "lane": "provider", "resourceId": "6PL28570JN503694M", "identity": "absent", "projection": { "phoneState": "paid", "applicationStatus": "PAID", "providerStatus": "CAPTURE COMPLETED", "capturedMinor": 2400, "refundedMinor": 0, "captureCount": 2, "fulfillmentCount": 1, "currency": "USD" } }, { "id": "cc1bee91-c96a-4b5f-908d-1f56cfa1a20c", "sequence": 19, "kind": "resource_read", "lane": "provider", "resourceId": "6PL28570JN503694M", "identity": "absent", "projection": { "phoneState": "paid", "applicationStatus": "PAID", "providerStatus": "CAPTURE COMPLETED", "capturedMinor": 2400, "refundedMinor": 0, "captureCount": 2, "fulfillmentCount": 1, "currency": "USD" } }, { "id": "bde51b9d-76cf-4386-bcd5-6147b4ad1849", "sequence": 20, "kind": "refund_completed", "lane": "provider", "resourceId": "2TY77369FW268003W", "requestId": "3d74f946-c02f-4d6e-8eb7-054073143b19", "identity": "stable", "projection": { "phoneState": "paid", "applicationStatus": "PAID", "providerStatus": "REFUND COMPLETED", "capturedMinor": 2400, "refundedMinor": 1200, "captureCount": 2, "fulfillmentCount": 1, "currency": "USD" } } ], "independentResources": [ { "kind": "order", "id": "7KN35440AK973631C", "status": "COMPLETED", "money": null, "parentId": null, "observedAt": "2026-11-11T04:59:41.840Z" }, { "kind": "capture", "id": "5X59700848833580D", "status": "COMPLETED", "money": { "currency": "USD", "minor": 1200 }, "parentId": "7KN35440AK973631C", "observedAt": "2026-11-11T04:59:41.841Z" }, { "kind": "order", "id": "54142017F86464930", "status": "COMPLETED", "money": null, "parentId": null, "observedAt": "2026-11-11T04:59:42.464Z" }, { "kind": "capture", "id": "6PL28570JN503694M", "status": "REFUNDED", "money": { "currency": "USD", "minor": 1200 }, "parentId": "54142017F86464930", "observedAt": "2026-11-11T04:59:42.464Z" }, { "kind": "refund", "id": "2TY77369FW268003W", "status": "COMPLETED", "money": { "currency": "USD", "minor": 1200 }, "parentId": "54142017F86464930", "observedAt": "2026-11-11T04:59:42.464Z" }, { "kind": "capture", "id": "5X59700848833580D", "status": "COMPLETED", "money": { "currency": "USD", "minor": 1200 }, "parentId": null, "observedAt": "2026-11-11T04:59:42.943Z" }, { "kind": "capture", "id": "6PL28570JN503694M", "status": "REFUNDED", "money": { "currency": "USD", "minor": 1200 }, "parentId": null, "observedAt": "2026-11-11T04:59:43.493Z" }, { "kind": "refund", "id": "2TY77369FW268003W", "status": "COMPLETED", "money": { "currency": "USD", "minor": 1200 }, "parentId": null, "observedAt": "2026-11-11T04:59:43.970Z" } ] }, { "id": "e0e738d9-8221-4273-a38a-a59faa4367f3", "revision": "hardened", "sourceHash": "0901229e503e27fcdbdeded49583b29cc0547b0c241ecc0a1813b6e56d9e438f", "scenarioHash": "cc468b6346ef48908a0b2de11e9266e4e7e22cf2c23da07d665d6290b082e23c", "businessIntentId": "purchase-97709425-0ca7-4db5-802b-17e7a54fa40c", "orderIds": [ "06S40047FT026892R" ], "captures": [ { "id": "28V18548TL196491H", "orderId": "06S40047FT026892R", "status": "COMPLETED", "amountMinor": 1200, "currency": "USD", "observedAt": "2026-11-11T04:57:53.414Z", "source": "live_sandbox", "evidenceId": "8d4f9ace-2d70-47e1-9ada-b73112145f6f" } ], "refunds": [], "events": [ { "id": "a79bf0ba-c4f9-48bd-be26-0855413bdb12", "sequence": 1, "kind": "checkout_started", "lane": "application", "identity": "stable", "projection": { "phoneState": "ready", "applicationStatus": "UNPAID", "providerStatus": "NO PAYMENT", "capturedMinor": 0, "refundedMinor": 0, "captureCount": 0, "fulfillmentCount": 0, "currency": "USD" } }, { "id": "7ddc8f37-68e9-46c6-bca7-710dd1c693f7", "sequence": 2, "kind": "order_payer_action_required", "lane": "provider", "resourceId": "06S40047FT026892R", "requestId": "e4624298-df7f-43bc-a36d-420d34ec95d0", "identity": "stable", "projection": { "phoneState": "ready", "applicationStatus": "UNPAID", "providerStatus": "ORDER CREATED", "capturedMinor": 0, "refundedMinor": 0, "captureCount": 0, "fulfillmentCount": 0, "currency": "USD" } }, { "id": "ce1eeae1-6f31-4ded-bb9e-7142ddf56ef8", "sequence": 3, "kind": "resource_read", "lane": "provider", "resourceId": "06S40047FT026892R", "identity": "absent", "projection": { "phoneState": "ready", "applicationStatus": "UNPAID", "providerStatus": "ORDER CREATED", "capturedMinor": 0, "refundedMinor": 0, "captureCount": 0, "fulfillmentCount": 0, "currency": "USD" } }, { "id": "0d46567d-e5b0-4f85-8ef8-c04990f09613", "sequence": 4, "kind": "resource_read", "lane": "provider", "resourceId": "06S40047FT026892R", "identity": "absent", "projection": { "phoneState": "ready", "applicationStatus": "UNPAID", "providerStatus": "ORDER APPROVED", "capturedMinor": 0, "refundedMinor": 0, "captureCount": 0, "fulfillmentCount": 0, "currency": "USD" } }, { "id": "b4766649-9abf-4069-834f-b3986d8c5770", "sequence": 5, "kind": "buyer_approved", "lane": "customer", "resourceId": "06S40047FT026892R", "identity": "not_applicable", "projection": { "phoneState": "ready", "applicationStatus": "UNPAID", "providerStatus": "ORDER APPROVED", "capturedMinor": 0, "refundedMinor": 0, "captureCount": 0, "fulfillmentCount": 0, "currency": "USD" } }, { "id": "dde904ca-2fb0-4840-b432-c8469f65f809", "sequence": 6, "kind": "checkout_claimed", "lane": "application", "identity": "stable", "projection": { "phoneState": "ready", "applicationStatus": "UNPAID", "providerStatus": "ORDER APPROVED", "capturedMinor": 0, "refundedMinor": 0, "captureCount": 0, "fulfillmentCount": 0, "currency": "USD" } }, { "id": "699b0919-f073-437e-8331-131f7a6aaea4", "sequence": 7, "kind": "resource_read", "lane": "provider", "resourceId": "06S40047FT026892R", "identity": "absent", "projection": { "phoneState": "ready", "applicationStatus": "UNPAID", "providerStatus": "ORDER APPROVED", "capturedMinor": 0, "refundedMinor": 0, "captureCount": 0, "fulfillmentCount": 0, "currency": "USD" } }, { "id": "3630d271-f153-4ac2-b928-e8759a8dfa13", "sequence": 8, "kind": "capture_completed", "lane": "provider", "resourceId": "28V18548TL196491H", "requestId": "5d417ddc-b7fe-49b7-bcac-682cc60bc852", "identity": "stable", "projection": { "phoneState": "ready", "applicationStatus": "UNPAID", "providerStatus": "CAPTURE COMPLETED", "capturedMinor": 1200, "refundedMinor": 0, "captureCount": 1, "fulfillmentCount": 0, "currency": "USD" } }, { "id": "30d43fdf-374a-4dcc-8b74-9a3a8616d212", "sequence": 9, "kind": "response_dropped", "lane": "lab", "identity": "not_applicable", "projection": { "phoneState": "ready", "applicationStatus": "UNPAID", "providerStatus": "CAPTURE COMPLETED", "capturedMinor": 1200, "refundedMinor": 0, "captureCount": 1, "fulfillmentCount": 0, "currency": "USD" } }, { "id": "8fc1b67a-7df6-44aa-9314-69c43dd0f453", "sequence": 10, "kind": "checking_unknown", "lane": "application", "identity": "stable", "projection": { "phoneState": "checking", "applicationStatus": "CHECKING", "providerStatus": "CAPTURE COMPLETED", "capturedMinor": 1200, "refundedMinor": 0, "captureCount": 1, "fulfillmentCount": 0, "currency": "USD" } }, { "id": "b1796388-aa4b-4efe-a8dd-41af2bbc1514", "sequence": 11, "kind": "resource_read", "lane": "provider", "resourceId": "28V18548TL196491H", "identity": "absent", "projection": { "phoneState": "checking", "applicationStatus": "CHECKING", "providerStatus": "CAPTURE COMPLETED", "capturedMinor": 1200, "refundedMinor": 0, "captureCount": 1, "fulfillmentCount": 0, "currency": "USD" } }, { "id": "f220098e-9475-4f15-994f-b4aa4d78b97a", "sequence": 12, "kind": "resource_read", "lane": "provider", "resourceId": "28V18548TL196491H", "identity": "absent", "projection": { "phoneState": "checking", "applicationStatus": "CHECKING", "providerStatus": "CAPTURE COMPLETED", "capturedMinor": 1200, "refundedMinor": 0, "captureCount": 1, "fulfillmentCount": 0, "currency": "USD" } }, { "id": "ef8047cf-ea48-4944-b275-717a08975468", "sequence": 13, "kind": "fulfilled", "lane": "application", "resourceId": "28V18548TL196491H", "identity": "stable", "projection": { "phoneState": "paid", "applicationStatus": "PAID", "providerStatus": "CAPTURE COMPLETED", "capturedMinor": 1200, "refundedMinor": 0, "captureCount": 1, "fulfillmentCount": 1, "currency": "USD" } }, { "id": "ec8a9076-eaa0-4cbc-bb51-afd591d3520f", "sequence": 14, "kind": "resource_read", "lane": "provider", "resourceId": "28V18548TL196491H", "identity": "absent", "projection": { "phoneState": "paid", "applicationStatus": "PAID", "providerStatus": "CAPTURE COMPLETED", "capturedMinor": 1200, "refundedMinor": 0, "captureCount": 1, "fulfillmentCount": 1, "currency": "USD" } }, { "id": "ea9dbab3-f2b0-431a-8b67-06803445845c", "sequence": 15, "kind": "recovery_read", "lane": "lab", "identity": "not_applicable", "projection": { "phoneState": "paid", "applicationStatus": "PAID", "providerStatus": "CAPTURE COMPLETED", "capturedMinor": 1200, "refundedMinor": 0, "captureCount": 1, "fulfillmentCount": 1, "currency": "USD" } } ], "independentResources": [ { "kind": "order", "id": "06S40047FT026892R", "status": "COMPLETED", "money": null, "parentId": null, "observedAt": "2026-11-11T04:59:44.506Z" }, { "kind": "capture", "id": "28V18548TL196491H", "status": "COMPLETED", "money": { "currency": "USD", "minor": 1200 }, "parentId": "06S40047FT026892R", "observedAt": "2026-11-11T04:59:44.506Z" }, { "kind": "capture", "id": "28V18548TL196491H", "status": "COMPLETED", "money": { "currency": "USD", "minor": 1200 }, "parentId": null, "observedAt": "2026-11-11T04:59:44.999Z" } ] } ], "limitations": [ "One explicitly approved sandbox comparison, not a statistical reliability benchmark.", "Response loss is controlled by the local lab after observing the real upstream response.", "The first baseline purchase and its retry received separate actual payer approvals.", "An earlier unapproved popup attempt was cancelled with no capture and is retained separately.", "No real money or physical fulfillment is claimed." ] }